Wins
| Year & Award | Category & Movie |
| 2007 – ShoWest Award | Female Star of the Year N/A |
| 2003 – Empire Award | Best Actress Spiderman |
| 2003 – MTV Movie Award | Best Female Performance Spiderman |
| 2003- MTV Movie Award | Best Kiss Spiderman |
| 2002 – Teen Choice Award | Film – Choice Lip Lock Spiderman |
| 2002 – Mar del Plata Film Festival | Best Actress The Cat’s Meow |
| 1998 – YoungStar Award | Best Performance by a Young Actress in a Miniseries/Made-for-TV Movie Fifteen and Pregnant |
| 1997 – YoungStar Award | Best Performance by a Young Actress in a Made For TV Movie The Siege at Ruby Ridge |
| 1995 – YoungStar Award | Best Performance by a Young Actress in a Drama Film Interview with the Vampire |
| 1995 – MTV Movie Award | Best Breakthrough Performance Interview with the Vampire |
| 1995 – Saturn Award | Best Performance by a Younger Actor Interview with the Vampire |
| 1995 – Young Artist Award | Best Performance by a Young Actress Co-Starring in a Motion Picture Little Women |
| 1994 – BSFC Award | Best Supporting Actress Interview with the Vampire |
Nominations
| Year & Award | Category & Movie |
| 2008 – Blimp Award | Favorite Female Movie Star Spiderman 3 |
| 2008 – People’s Choice Award | Favorite On Screen Match-up Spiderman 3 |
| 2007 – People’s Choice Award | Favorite Leading Lady |
| 2007 – Teen Choice Award | Choice Movie: Liplock Spiderman 3 |
| 2007 – Teen Choice Award | Choice Movie Actress: Action Adventure Spiderman 3 |
| 2007 – National Movie Award | Best Performance by a Female Spiderman 3 |
| 2005 – People’s Choice Award | Favorite On-Screen Chemistry Spiderman 2 |
| 2005 – Empire Award | Best Actress Spiderman 2 |
| 2004 – Teen Choice Award | Choice Movie Sleazebag Mona Lisa Smile |
| 2003 – Blimp Award | Favorite Movie Actress Spiderman |
| 2003 – Saturn Award | Best Actress Spiderman |
| 2002 – Teen Choice Award | Film – Choice Chemistry Spiderman |
| 2002 – Teen Choice Award | Film – Choice Actress, Drama/Action Adventure Spiderman |
| 2001 – Blockbuster Entertainment Award | Favorite Actress – Comedy Bring It On |
| 2001 – Teen Choice Award | Film – Choice Chemistry Bring It On |
| 2001 – Teen Choice Award | Film – Choice Actress Bring It On |
| 2001 – Video Premiere Award | Best Actress All Forgotten |
| 2001 – Young Artist Award | Best Performance in a Feature Film Leading Young Actress Bring It On |
| 2000 – Young Artist Award | Best Performance in a TV Movie or Pilot Leading Young Actress The Devil’s Arithmetic |
| 2000 – Teen Choice Award | Film – Choice Actress The Virgin Suicides |
| 2000 – Teen Choice Award | Film – Choice Actress |
| 1997 – YoungStar Award | The Virgin Suicides |
| 1997 – >YoungStar Award | Best Young Actress/Performance in a Motion Picture Comedy Dick |
| 1999 – Young Artist Award | Best Performance in a Feature Film Leading Young Actress Small Soldiers |
| 1998 – Young Artist Award | Best Performance in a TV Movie/Pilot/Mini-Series Leading Young Actress Tower of Terror |
| 1997 – Young Artist Award | Best Performance in a Drama Series Guest Starring Young Actress ER |
| 1997 – YoungStar Award | Best Performance by a Young Actress in a Drama TV Series ER |
| 1996 – Young Artist Award | Best Young Leading Actress – Feature Film Jumanji |
| 1996 – Saturn Award | Best Performance by a Younger Actor Jumanji |
| 1995 – Golden Globe | Best Performance by an Actress in a Supporting Role in a Motion Picture Interview with the Vampire |
| 1995 – Chlotrudis Award | Best Supporting Actress Little Women |